Reynolds played 320 games for the Bombers, kicked 442 goals and played in four premierships. Among his many playing honors were seven Essendon Football Club Best and Fairest awards and three Brownlow Medals. The final 25 Essendon players ranked in order were:
1. Dick Reynolds
2. John Coleman
3. James Hird
4. Bill Hutchison
5. Simon Madden
6. Tim Watson
7. Ken Fraser
8. Jack Clarke
9. Albert Thurgood
10. Tom Fitzmaurice
11. Terry Daniher
12. Wally Buttsworth
13. Reg Burgess
14. Bill Busbridge
15. Barry Davis
16. Keith Forbes
17. Graham Moss
18. Mark Harvey
19. Gavin Wanganeen
20. Mark Thompson
21. John Birt
22. Matthew Lloyd
23. Michael Long
24. Fred Baring
25. Harold Lambert
Selection Panel: Kevin Sheedy, Tim Watson, Ken Fraser, Brian Donohoe. Peter Jackson (non-voting chairman).
Overall Panel Comments:“This was undoubtedly a most difficult task to undertake and one that is certain to create much conversation and some controversy. Essendon Football Club has been blessed with many wonderful players and to even determine the initial 60 from which this 25 were selected was an onerous task on its own.
In ranking these players, they were assessed on the performance of the team at the time they played and on any individual recognition they received during this period. Best and fairest awards and captaincy were ranked more highly in Premiership years and in successful eras. Another significant consideration in ranking these players was their ability to dominate and alter the course of matches.”
Dick Reynolds:
“Dick was a magnificent leader and player at the Essendon Football Club. His record, and that of the sides he played with, is remarkable. Reynolds would dominate games from start to finish – he was a match winner who inspired those who played alongside him. Based on our selection criteria, Dick Reynolds is clearly the greatest player this club has seen.
John Coleman:
“John was a freakish talent and his goal-kicking exploits in his 98 games are beyond compare. A sensational mark and an accurate kick, he dominated games from the goal square. John Coleman was a clear second in the player rankings.
James Hird:
“James is one of the greatest leaders this club has had – his courage and skill has inspired his teammates. While James’ individual record is yet to reach the heights of others, his ability to dominate and alter the course of matches is equal to that of anyone to have played for Essendon.”
