Brett Crabtree from Adelaide says: Mark Mercuri is the best finisher in the AFL, either kicking to a teamate or kicking for goal, and is very cool and calm under intense pressure. Blake Caracella is also widely acknowledged as the most accurate kick for goal in the league, however I would still nominate Mark.
Meg from Moorabbin says: You really have to define the type of kick, outside the 50 would be Scott Lucas with out a doubt, Blake never misses from anywhere inside about 35m and Lloydy is pretty good from any angle
David Lovelock from East Keilor says: I think that either one of those players could kick the winning goal, in fact I think most players on the team would be able to.
Justin Grossbard from Caulfield says: I think Lucas is the most accurate kick outside 50 so I would always trust him to kick a goal outside 50 but inside 50 it is hard to go against Lloyd.
Clint from Perth says: Inside 50m definitely Caracella, but outside 50m Lloyd or Lucas would be the go as they can both kick accurately up to about 60m on their day.
Nigel Leitch from Horsham says: Of all the Essendon players kicking at goal after the siren I would most like to see the ball in the hands of Jason Johnson. Of these players though I would back Blake Carracella 90% of the time.
Maureen McIntosh from Bayswater North says: Lloydy would not let us down. He has such great concentration, especially when it matters most.
Timothy Truscott from Essendon, Victoria, Australia says: Even though Matty Lloyd is a wonderful kick for goal, Blake Caracella would have to be the most accurate kick for goal in the AFL. After the siren in a Grand Final, accuracy is whats needed.
Harry Smith from Ivanhoe Vic Australia says: All of the players would kick the goal if they had to...
